Friday, February 3, 2012

Editor’s Review: HBO’s “Luck”

Editors Review: HBOs Luck   HBO Luck Racing

HBO's Luck | Courtesy of HBO

As much as we’d like to fall in love with an equestrian-themed television series, we don’t think HBO’s “Luck” is going to be the one.

The series pilot (Episode 1) has been critiqued elsewhere as long on character development, short on plot. We concur and, while denizens of the track are typically a real lot of characters, the opening episode left us wondering whether we cared what happens next.

The most appealing part of the track, for us anyway, is the horses and Luck does offer lots of long Thoroughbred legs and spectacularly-shot racing footage. (There’s also some inaccuracies in the horse scenes that an equestrian watcher will surely spot.)

The least appealing part of the track (again, for us) is the betting, and this, unfortunately, is where “Luck” casts the bulk of it’s attention.

Two of racings most photogenic jockeys, Gary Stevens and Chantal Sutherland, lend an air of authenticity to an already impressive cast, including Dustin Hoffman, Dennis Farina, Richard Kind, Nick Nolte, Jill Hennessy among them.

Let’s just say we were intrigued enough to plan on watching Episode 2, but there are a few areas where we hope  - but aren’t confident – “Luck” will improve:

Though the track has always been a man’s world, there are many women that earn their living on the backside – as trainers, vets, exercise riders, and jockeys – and we hope “Luck’s” female characters will play more than a peripheral role.

And, from it’s opening sequence, “Luck” pivots on the notion of the horse as a redemptive force in man’s world. Romantic and appealing as that notion is, we’re not as comfortable with the horse as pawn as “Luck’s” producers may be.

Interested viewers beware, Episode 1 includes a graphic mid-race breakdown scene with an audible snap. We apologize for the spoiler, but we know it’s one  a lot of equestrians appreciate.

“Luck” airs on HBO on Sundays at 9pm.

 

 

 

 

 

Every week, Dappled Grey sends our subscribers our free weekly Style Guide. Peruse our fabulous previous editions here.

  • LeeAnne Deardorff Goen

    Mr. Smith isn’t too realistic but it is clear they based Delphi on Alydar and his murder for insurance money by the evil son in law…

  • Dappled Grey

    Just watched the most recent episode- really seems like it is getting more realistic. I love Ace watching his horse on the camera!

  • LeeAnne Deardorff Goen

    I thoroughly enjoy seeing Gary Stevens playing such a washed up foul mouthed jerk, he really has a future as an actor. I do think it portrays only negatives about racing which isn’t going to help anything.

  • Bailey Gallison

    Like Zenyatta, Luck may have started slow from the gate, but it’s gonna give a great ride and be winning at the wire ;)

  • Linda Shantz

    I agree, after a shaky start, it’s improved. As someone who has worked in the industry for many years, I get depressed when I see show after show portraying racing as just about gambling and drugs and breakdowns, when it’s not.

  • Tonya Johnston

    It has grown on me too… I have only seen four episodes so far, but I want to find out what happens!!

  • Nancy Bannerman

    I think the show will shed some light on the often horrible practices that’ve been a part of thoroughbred racing in this country. I’m liking the introduction of the positives, like thoroughbred rescues, and the impact of working with horses as therapy for prisoners.

  • Tory Schanzle

    I’ve been watching Luck since the beginning. I was impressed with last nights show, where Ace visited the Thoroughbred rescue , that he funded. I was impressed with the owner talking to Ace about gaining respect of the horses and the prisoners she has working with the rescued TBs. Sounded like shes into natural horsemanship!!

  • http://www.thedesplainescasino.com/blog/review-of-hbos-luck-episode-4-the-metaphysical-dialogues mattnewman
  • Dappled Grey

    Jessica Shannon We’ve added a link about this to the original post

  • Jessica Shannon

    I read two horses died during production, but I can’t verify it. If you google it, lots of PETA sites come up.

  • Jeff Lennan

    This page on American Humane’s site is interesting. They are the entity that monitors the use of animals in TV and film. They gave War Horse a rating of “outstanding” while giving Luck a “special circumstance” rating.

    http://www.americanhumanefilmtv.org/reviews/

  • Bekah Sydnor

    lol yup!

  • Dappled Grey

    Totally Bekah Swink. Even our horse husband noticed those things and when they were talking in front of a horse’s stall and then two seconds later the rider was swinging a leg over – never seen anyone tack up that quickly!

  • Bekah Sydnor

    and coming from a racing backround its just silly to me. and the horse switching thing always bugs the crap outta me! if you start out with a solid bay, dont switch to a copper chestnut with a blaze.. hahaha

  • Dappled Grey

    I agree Laurel Jacobus. Just watched episode 2 and I covered my eyes/ ears during the racing scene as precaution. Not enjoyable!

  • Laurel Jacobus

    I happened to catch the premier close to the end with the breakdown on the track. Hoping it was CGI but a bit too graphic for me. Think most of us that have been around for awhile have had to deal with equine death. Even if the horses are “acting” its just a little too tough for me to watch. Didn’t think the rest of the story made up for it.

  • Thomas michaels

    Worst part is inability to understand the spoken words. Just terrible!

    • http://twitter.com/dappledgrey Molly

      LOL. Well, I can’t do anything about the annunciation but LUCK has been trying to help non-familiar viewers understand racing jargon. http://www.facebook.com/LuckHBO?sk=notes

  • http://www.journalismaccelerator.com Jeff

    This page on American Humane’s site is interesting. They gave War Horse a rating of “outstanding” while giving Luck a “special circumstance” rating.

    http://www.americanhumanefilmtv.org/reviews/

  • http://www.ollieandfriends.co Jessica Shannon

    I saw the first episode and will give it another try. Is there any truth to the rumor that two horses died during production (not as part of the plot)?

  • http://www.thedesplainescasino.com/?p=1827. matthew newman

    This is a review of Episode 2 from HBO’s Luck, starring Dustin Hoffman,
    http://www.thedesplainescasino.com/?p=1827.
    Excerpt: In the first episode, the pick six crew were riding high based on a $2,700,000 win. In this episode, each of the newly bankrolled losers are rapidly spiraling back to earth. Jerry is losing his shirt at a casino. Lonnie shows up in a new suit, “putting on airs,” and gets jumped by two women who beat up him for bailing on an insurance scam they all had previously planned. Another one of the pick six crew wants to go legit and become a horse owner, but is unsuccessful. The ringleader, the acerbic, wheelchair bound Marcus, is bitter and unable to find any joy because to announce his newfound fortune is a betrayal of the code that he is bound by.

Previous post:

Next post: